Posted by Michael David Smith on October 27, 2008, 11:45 a.m.
During Saturday’s Michigan-Michigan State game, Michigan receiver Brandon Minor jumped for a pass and came down out of bounds as his foot kicked the pylon. The official was right on top of the play, correctly ruled it an incomplete pass, and that should have been that.
But that wasn’t that. For some odd reason, the replay official reviewed the clearly correct call and changed it, awarding Minor a touchdown.
Now the Big Ten has acknowledged that the official overruled the play because he was ignorant of the rules — he thought touching the pylon is the same as touching the ground. It’s not.
“The people in the replay booth made a mistake,” Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany said. “It wasn’t a mistake of judgment; it was a mistake of an application of the rule. They applied the wrong rule and they applied it improperly. … I expect more from them than that. You can understand a mistake of judgment on the field, and you can even understand possibly not getting the standard right because we want indisputable video evidence that a play is wrong. But to apply the wrong rule to a situation is not acceptable to me.”
Delany is a stand-up guy, and he’s right to acknowledge this mistake. Next he should hand down disciplinary action for the official in question. He says that it’s possible he will, although if he does he won’t announce it publicly.
“There has to be an understanding that we expect on the field and in the booth 100% knowledge of the rules, applying the right rule to the right situation,” Delany said. “You might make a mistake in terms of judgment, but I expect our officials to know the rules and apply the right rule to the right situation. We didn’t do that, and that’s not acceptable.”
Absolutely right it’s not acceptable. Fortunately, the blown call didn’t cost Michigan State the game; the Spartans won 35-21.
Here’s the play in question: